High-Speed Interface Layout Guidelines - TI

High-Speed Interface Layout Guidelines (Rev. J) - Texas Instruments

Per Gemini - Google AI

There are actually two main reasons why differential signals are not always preferred for routing on the outer layers of a printed circuit board (PCB), and it has to do with the type of transmission line formed:

Microstrip vs. Stripline:

Outer layers create microstrip transmission lines, where the signal trace has a reference plane on one side (usually a power plane) and air on the other.

Differential signals rely on a consistent and symmetrical environment for optimal performance. Microstrip, due to its air exposure, introduces an asymmetry that can affect the common-mode vs. differential-mode propagation characteristics.

Controlled Impedance:

Precise control over the impedance of the transmission line is crucial for high-speed differential signals. Microstrip's impedance is more sensitive to variations in manufacturing tolerances compared to stripline.

However, there are some advantages to routing differential signals on outer layers:

Slightly Faster Signal Propagation:

Outer layers have a lower effective dielectric constant due to the presence of air. This can lead to marginally faster signal travel compared to inner layer routing.

Easier Access for Controlled-Impedance Routing Techniques:

The outer layers are more accessible for adding solder masks or prepreg layers to adjust the trace width and spacing, allowing for finer control over impedance.

In conclusion, the decision to route differential signals on outer layers depends on the specific application's priorities. For high-performance applications where signal integrity is paramount, stripline routing on inner layers with a controlled and symmetrical environment is usually preferred. However, for lower-speed applications where manufacturability and ease of access are important, outer layer routing with microstrip can be a viable option, considering the trade-offs mentioned above.

That's it !